Historical article. This content reflects the original publication date. Dimensis
FACUA-Consumidores en Acción described findings by Spain's Data Protection Agency (AEPD) as a victory in its challenge to Gmail's advertising model. FACUA had filed a complaint in October alleging that Google infringed privacy by scanning incoming and outgoing messages to show personalized ads based on their content.
For nearly four years, FACUA had argued that Gmail and other providers using the same practices intruded on the privacy of people who signed up for a free account with 6 GB of storage, as well as people who sent messages to those accounts.
FACUA wrote to Google that day to urge it to comply with data protection rules. It was the group's third approach in nearly four years and followed analysis by Spanish and European privacy authorities.
FACUA calls for changes to Gmail's advertising
FACUA said Gmail could continue operating if Google stopped linking ads to email content. It cited examples such as showing funeral ads to a user after a death in the family or promoting loans after the user's bank rejected payments for insufficient funds.
The group argued that a free service and automated processing did not justify limiting privacy rights. It warned that scanning emails for ads could set a precedent for doing the same with phone calls.
The Secretariat of State for Telecommunications, which also received FACUA's complaint, referred the matter to the AEPD, which had enforcement powers. In a letter dated 29 October, the secretariat said the facts in the complaint could constitute a breach of Article 21 of Law 34/2002 of 11 July on Information Society Services and Electronic Commerce.
FACUA said the agency's analysis supported its argument that scanning messages for advertising, even automatically, conflicted with Spanish and European rules. The group first raised its objections with Google in April 2004, when the company announced Gmail's launch in the United States. At that time, FACUA joined a coalition of groups from the United States, Canada and the European Union opposing the practice.
In a December statement on internet search engines, the AEPD said it did not consider interception of message content consistent with Spanish law.
The AEPD recognized an exception for scanning messages to protect the service, such as detecting viruses and spam. Even in that case, it said providers should disclose their email screening practices and let subscribers decide whether to use spam filtering.
FACUA was still waiting for a formal response to its complaint from the AEPD. It argued that Google needed to change Gmail advertising in Spain and across the European Union.
European opinion
The data protection authorities of EU member states, the European Data Protection Supervisor and the European Commission had issued an opinion more than a year earlier. Based on Google's response when FACUA first raised the complaint before taking it to the Spanish authorities, FACUA said the company had appeared to overlook the opinion.
Opinion 2/2006 came from the Article 29 Working Party, an independent advisory body bringing together those authorities. It examined when service providers could scan email content.
As the AEPD explained, the opinion said providers could filter communications to prevent viruses and spam and take appropriate technical and organizational measures to secure their services under Article 4 of Directive 2002/58/EC on privacy in electronic communications. Spain implemented that article through Article 34 of its General Telecommunications Law 32/2003.
FACUA's reading of the rules was that Google would have to change its business model in the EU. In its view, charging some customers for email without content-based ads and providing the existing service to others for free would still leave the underlying problem unresolved.